Federal Trade Commission Received Documents Jan 19 1996 B18354900065 Secretary American Wire Producers Association "Steel Wire and Wire Products for America and the World" 515 King Street Alexandria, VA 2314-3103 Phone: 703/549-6003 Fax: 703/684-6048 Kimberly A. Korbel Executive Director January 19, 1996 HAND DELIVERED Office of the Secretary Federal Trade Commission Room 159 Pennsylvania Avenue & 6th Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20508 Re: "Made in USA" Policy Comment File No. P894219 Dear Sir/Madam: On behalf of the members of the American Wire Producers Association, we respectfully submit the following comments regarding the use of "Made in USA" or "Made in America" claims in product labeling and advertising. We understand that these comments will be considered by the Commission in preparation for a public workshop on this subject. The American Wire Producers Association ("AWPA") is a trade association which represents American manufacturers of steel wire and wire products, including barbed wire, wire strand and rope, woven and welded wire mesh and fabric, nails, springs, and wire coat hangers. The members of the AWPA purchase carbon, stainless and other alloy steel wire rod from domestic and foreign sources, and they process or "draw" the wire rod into steel wire which may then be further processed into wire products. Major consumers of steel wire and wire products include the automotive, agricultural and construction industries. The AWPA also includes virtually all U.S. and Canadian manufacturers of steel wire rod as well as 70 to 80 percent of all U.S. manufacturers of wire and wire products and wire producers in Canada and Mexico. The 89 members of the AWPA operate 220 plants in 35 states, and they employ 60,000 American workers. It is estimated that total annual shipments by AWPA members exceed $15 billion in value. The members of the AWPA have been actively involved with the U.S. Customs Service for more than twelve years in its formulation of rules of origin for foreign and domestically produced steel wire and wire products. These origination rules have generally held that steel wire which is processed in the United States from imported wire rod is not "substantially transformed" and, therefore, remains a product of the country in which the wire rod was produced. The origination rules of the U.S. Customs Service also generally provide that the manufacture of wire products in the United States constitutes a "substantial transformation" of the underlying steel wire and wire rod, making the United States the country of origin of the finished product. Recently, members of the AWPA were involved in a ruling by the U.S. Customs Service concerning the origination rules and marking requirements for steel wire manufactured from imported wire rod. This ruling addresses the "Made in USA" issue being considered by the Commission. Briefly, the U.S. Customs Service has interpreted its origination rules to require domestic producers of steel wire which is processed from foreign-source wire rod to mark such wire as a product of the foreign country in which the wire rod was produced. The U.S. Customs Service took this position even in those cases in which domestic wire producers performed significant and multiple manufacturing processes on the imported wire rod. Nevertheless, the U.S. Customs Service has also allowed domestic wire producers to label or mark such wire as "Processed in USA" and "Drawn in USA" in addition to the required labeling or marking of "Product of (country)" of rod production. Attached for the Commission's review and information are (1) a copy of the ruling request concerning the marking of steel wire processed in the United States from imported wire rod and (2) a copy of the ruling by the U.S. Customs Service in response to that request. The members of the AWPA appreciate this opportunity to submit these comments to the Commission for its consideration, and we look forward to working with the Commission toward the goal of establishing clear, consistent and predictable standards for "Made in USA" labeling of our products. We invite the Commission to contact us if it has any questions about these comments or if the members of the AWPA can be of further assistance. We intend to apply for participation in the Commission's workshop when a formal notice and request for applications are published in the Federal Register. Very truly yours, John S. Mueller President