Submission Number: 00200
Received: 12/10/2010 9:40:49 AM
Commenter: Dale Boone
Organization: Intermountain Auto Recycling, Inc
Agency: Federal Trade Commission
Initiative: Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims; Project No. P954501
Attachments: No Attachments
Dec 10, 2010
Mr. Donald Clark
Office of the Secretary
Federal Trade Commission 600 Pennsylvania Ave, NW
Washington, DC 20580
Dear Mr. Clark:
My name is Dale Boone and I am vice-president of Intermountain Auto Recycling inc. I would like to submit comments on the proposed modifications and additions to the Federal Trade Commission's (FTC) Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing Claims (Guides), as published in the October 15, 2010 edition of the Federal Register. I continue to support the use of the Guides and am pleased to learn that the existing Guide language addressing the recycled content claims (Sec. 260.12) for automotive parts (see Sec 260.12, Examples 12 and 13) is retained.
However, I believe that the language in these examples should be amended as follows to specifically include automobile recyclers:
Example 12: An automotive dealer, automobile recycler or other qualified entity recovers a serviceable engine from a wrecked vehicle. Without repairing, rebuilding, re-manufacturing, or in any way altering the engine or its components, the dealer attaches a “Recycled” label to the engine, and offers it for sale in its used auto parts store. In this situation, an unqualified recycled content claim likely is not deceptive because reasonable consumers likely would understand that the engine is used and has not undergone any rebuilding.
Example 13: An automobile parts dealer, automobile recycler or other qualified entity purchases a transmission that has been recovered from a junked vehicle. Eighty-five percent of the transmission, by weight, was rebuilt and 15% constitutes new materials. After rebuilding the transmission in accordance with industry practices, the dealer packages it for resale in a box labeled “Rebuilt Transmission,” or “Rebuilt Transmission (85% recycled content from rebuilt parts),” or “Recycled Transmission (85% recycled content from rebuilt parts).” These claims are not deceptive.
INDUSTRY LEADER - FTC's recognition that automobile parts recovered from vehicles are appropriately described as recycled, lends crucial support to the automotive recycling industry. But, I ask that the FTC go further and note specifically in the examples that automotive recyclers or other qualified entities recover the parts as state statues are very specific on this subject.
Ninety-five percent of all end-of-life vehicles in the U.S. go through a market-driven recycling infrastructure beginning with the automotive recycler. The suggested Guide language affirms recyclers' efforts to keep contaminants and hazardous materials out of landfills, water and air. In fact, every motor vehicle that is recycled saves 2,500 pounds of iron ore, 1,400 pounds of coal, and 120 pounds of limestone.
CONCLUSION - I appreciate FTC’s continued inclusion of language recognizing the legitimacy of the recycling descriptor for the management of older vehicles in the Guides and request that the existing language be changed as noted above.
Intermountain Auto Recycling, inc.